Supreme Court to pronounce verdict on Karnataka’s hijab ban on Thursday

Highlights
  • The Supreme Court is scheduled to pronounce on Thursday its verdict on a clutch of petitions challenging the Karnataka government’s February 5 order, prohibiting wearing of hijab inside classrooms in pre-university colleges.
  • According to the apex court website, the bench will pronounce the judgment on October 13.
  • After 10 days of marathon hearings, on September 22, a bench of Justices Hemant Gupta and Sudhanshu Dhulia reserved their judgment after hearing arguments from the counsel representing the state government, teachers, and the petitioners, who moved the apex court challenging the Karnataka High Court verdict refusing to lift the ban on hijab in educational institutions of the state.
  • During the hearing, the petitioners contended that the high court had wrongly relied upon essential religious practice test for the purpose.
  • Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, representing the Karnataka government, had alleged that till the year 2021, no girl student was wearing any hijab and uniform being part of essential discipline in schools was being scrupulously followed. However, then a movement started on social media by an organisation called Popular Front of India (PFI) and the movement was designed to create an agitation. Mehta added there were messages on social media to begin wearing hijab and this was not a spontaneous act, instead it was a part of larger conspiracy, and children were acting as advised.
  • Senior advocate Huzefa Ahmadi, representing some of the petitioners, submitted that the argument of PFI was not raised before the high court and it is an argument introduced to create prejudice.
  • The petitioners claimed the Karnataka government order (GO) targeted Muslim women and violated Article 14, and 15 of the Constitution. Therefore, it was irrational, arbitrary and unconstitutional.
  • Senior advocate Dushyant Dave, representing some of the petitioners, while making rejoinder submissions, said for those who are believers, hijab is essential and for those who are not believers, it is not essential. He added that there was no cause to issue guidelines in February this year.
  • The petitioners’ counsel vehemently argued that the government order violated their fundamental right to practice religion and cultural rights, which were guaranteed under the Constitution.
  • Dave submitted that the Department of Education had issued guidelines for academic year 2021-2022, and according to it, uniform is not compulsory. Therefore, Karnataka GO dated February 5 could not supersede these guidelines, he added.
  • A battery of other senior advocates — Rajeev Dhavan, Kapil Sibal, Colin Gonsalves, Devadatt Kamat, Sanjay Hegde, Salman Khurshid – also represented the petitioners before the apex court.
The Karnataka government was represented by Solicitor General Mehta and Advocate General Prabhuling K. Navadgi.

Bommai and Yediyurappa to begin statewide tour ahead of Karnataka polls

Highlights
  • Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai and BJP strongman B S Yediyurappa will kickstart the party’s election tour in the state from Raichur on Tuesday, in the run-up to assembly polls next year.
  • The duo are scheduled to cover 52 Assembly segments till December 25, as part of the ‘Jana Sankalpa Yatra’.
  • The ruling party’s tour begins at the time when Congress’ Bharat Jodo Yatra led by Rahul Gandhi is passing through the state.
  • “The intention of the Jana Sankalpa Yatra is to inform the programmes, work and policies of BJP government in the state and at the Centre, and also send a message to BJP office-bearers and workers to prepare for elections with a resolve to bring BJP back to power in the state,” Bommai said.
  • Speaking to reporters here ahead of leaving for Raichur, he said, “There is enthusiasm everywhere. Through the Jana Sankalpa Yatra, we hope to gain the confidence of the people and to be victorious in the 2023 assembly polls.”
  • According to the Chief Minister, during the tour, he will be interacting with beneficiaries of various schemes and visit certain places as planned by the local party functionaries. Responding to a question, Bommai said he and his party are not worried about Congress’ Bharat Jodo Yatra, and said the foot march has no impact.
  • “The world knows, it is ‘jodoing’ (uniting) whom and ‘thodoing’ (dividing) whom. It has no importance. We are not worried, we are doing our sankalpa (resolution) yatra to win the election by informing people about our programmes. There is no connection with it (BJP’s tour with Congress’ yatra),” he added.
Incidentally, BJP’s tour begins from Raichur Rural assembly segment, an ST reserve seat that has a huge presence of the Valmiki community. The state government had last week decided to hike the reservation quota for SCs from 15 per cent to 17 per cent and for STs from 3 per cent to 7 per cent.
The ‘Valmiki Gurupeetha’ seer Prasannananda Swami has been on a hunger strike demanding the ST quota hike. Bommai and Yediyurappa will be touring predominantly in the ‘Kalyana Karnataka’ region. Of the 52 seats which they will be touring, 20 constituencies are currently represented by Congress MLAs and four by JD(S).
Also, BJP state president Nalin Kumar Kateel will be touring Haveri, Gadag and Hubli-Dharwad over the next three days. The party has also planned seven rallies by — SC Morcha in Mysuru on October 16, OBC Morcha in Kalaburagi on October 30, Raitha (farmer) Morcha in Hubballi on November 13, Yuva (youth) Morcha in Shivamogga on November 27, ST Morcha in Ballari on November 27, Mahila (women) Morcha in Bengaluru on December 25 and Minority Morcha in Vijayapura on January 8 ahead of the polls.

How will you implement SC/ST quota hike, Siddaramaiah asks Bommai

Highlights
  • With the BJP going to town about the SC/ST quota hike, Leader of the Opposition Siddaramaiah on Monday asked Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai to spell out how his government plans to make sure the enhanced reservation would stand legally.
  • In a series of tweets, Siddaramaiah accused the BJP government of “falsely claiming credit” for the decision to increase SC/ST quota “without telling the process that went behind the decision.”
  • Last week, the Bommai administration decided to increase SC reservation from 15 per cent to 17 per cent and for STs from 3 per cent to 7 per cent.
  • Siddaramaiah said the BJP government had not provided clarity on how the SC/ST quota hike would be implemented. “Supreme Court had passed a judgement on the limit to the reservation in Indra Sawhney case. Can Bommai explain the strategy to pass the legal test?”
  • Welcoming the decision on the SC/ST quota hike, Siddaramaiah pointed out that it was the Congress-JD(S) coalition government that set up the Justice H N Nagamohan Das Commission whose recommendation led to the decision.
  • “Implementation of increase in reservation to SC/STs is a long process and needs political commitment of the ruling parties. Do BJP MPs or Bommai have the capacity to get the work done from their Union BJP government?” Siddaramaiah asked.
  • On Sunday, at the Maharshi Valmiki Jayanti event, Bommai declared that his government’s decision to increase SC/ST quota was in line with Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s ‘Sab ka Saath, Sab Ka Vikas, Sab Ka Vishwas’ call.

After SC/ST quota hike, reservation-related demands pile up in Karnataka

Highlights
  • With reservation-related demands from various communities intensifying following the state government’s decision to increase quota for SCs and STs, Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai on Tuesday said there are aspirations from all communities and appropriate decisions will be taken after due consideration.
  • There are reservation-related demands made by various communities — the Panchamasali Lingayats want to come under Category 2A of backward classes (they are now under Category 3B), Kurubas, who are currently OBCs, have been pushing to be bracketed under ST, while the Veerashaiva-Lingayats and Vokkaligas are keen to be included in the central OBC list.
  • “Naturally, everyone will have aspirations. We have taken up SC/ST communities first. We are working on giving legal protection regarding it (hike in SC/ST quota),” Bommai said in response to a question. Speaking to reporters here, he said, “On the matters (of reservation) related to backward classes, there is a permanent backward classes commission looking into it. There are experts too. Based on the recommendations made by the commission and taking experts’ opinion into account, the government will take appropriate decisions from time to time.”
  • The Karnataka Cabinet on October 8 accorded its formal approval to increase the quota for SCs and STs in the state. With this, the quota for SCs would go up from 15 per cent to 17 per cent and for STs from 3 per cent to 7 per cent. Following this, the government would also initiate the process to have it included under the Ninth Schedule of the Constitution by making a recommendation to the Centre.
  • The decision to hike SC/ST quota is being seen by some with a political prism, with Assembly elections due in about six months. The Bommai government was under tremendous pressure from SC/ST communities and lawmakers to hike the quota and also to implement the Justice H N Nagamohan Das commission’s report. Also, ‘Valmiki Gurupeetha’ seer Prasannananda Swami has been on a hunger strike demanding the ST quota hike.

BJP targets Siddaramaiah with ‘PFI Bhagya’ posters during Bharat Jodo Yatra in Karnataka

Highlights
  • To counter the ‘PayCM’ campaign launched by Congress, BJP has launched ‘PFI Bhagya’ featuring former chief minister Siddaramaiah in various parts of Challakere town along the route of the ongoing Bharat Jodo Yatra led by Congress leader Rahul Gandhi.
  • The posters, which read “To know terror bhagya and tactics of Siddramullah, scan this QR code” have been put up in the town in the early hours of Tuesday.

The photos featuring Siddaramaiah wearing Tipu Sultan ‘peta’ and holding a sword have also been put up below the flex banners of the Congress yatra.
The BJP had slammed Siddaramaiah when the former had demanded the Centre to ban RSS after it banned Popular Front of India (PFI)  and other Muslim organisations for their alleged anti-national activities. To counter it, PFI Bhagya posters had been put up in the town.

NGT suspends green nod to Kaiga expansion

Highlights
  • The National Green Tribunal has suspended the environmental clearances granted to Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited (NPCIL) for expansion of Kaiga Unit 5 and 6 citing procedural lapses.
  • The Southern Bench of the NGT, comprising Justice K Ramkrishnan (Judicial Member) and Satyagopal Korlapati (Environment Member), in its order, said that the environmental clearance granted to NPCIL for the expansion project of Kaiga Unit 5  and 6 by enhancing from 235 MW to 700 MW by the ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change is suspended. The clearance was granted in August 2019.
  • “Till the NPCIL gets its fresh environmental clearances, the project proponent is directed not to commence the commissioning of the project,” the order said.
  • However, the NGT said, “the NPCIL can proceed with the construction of the project subject to the further directions (if any) to be issued by the Ministry of Environment and Forest in this regard and at their risk.”
  • The NGT was hearing a petition filed by Kaiga Anuvidyut Sthawarada 5 & 6 Ghataka Virodhi Horata Samiti, Karwar, which challenged the validity of the environmental clearance. The petitioner alleged that the project falls in the Western Ghats eco-sensitive zone and setting up a nuclear power project, which is a red category industry, was a threat to biodiversity of the area.
  • The NGT also said that MoEF should issue additional terms of reference to the project proponent regarding whether project area falls within the eco-sensitive zone of Western Ghats and also how far the project will have impact on the Kaiga village.
  • The NGT also directed the NPCIL to conduct a study regarding the impact  on the health of local people due to atomic radiation from these units.

Hubballi-Ankola rail line: Will address concerns, says minister

Highlights
  • Union Railways Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw, referring to the Hubballi-Ankola Rail line project, said on Tuesday that the concerns, expressed by those opposing the project, would be addressed.
  • Those, opposing the project, would be convinced that it would be taken up without harming the ecology. He noted this while speaking after inaugurating the redeveloped Dharwad railway station.
  • The proposed railway line will be executed in a balanced way without disturbing the rich bio-diversity of the Western Ghats. A case regarding the project is pending before the High Court, and after getting clearance, the works will be taken up on a fast track, he said. He asked the local leaders to hold talks with environmentalists opposing the project and take them into confidence.
  • On the occasion, the minister announced that the weekly Hubballi-Varanasi train would be run twice a week and the new train Hubballi-Nizamuddin would be named after
    Pandit Savai Gandharva.
  • He also assured that a new train between Hubballi and Sabarimala would be started within three months for the benefit of the devotees.
  • The Dharwad station has been redeveloped at a cost of Rs 20.4 crore. The new building shows a perfect amalgamation of modern architecture with the culture of Dharwad.

Bharat Jodo Yatra: Bhaag DK Bhaag, keeps pace with RaGa

Highlights
  • “Some days you walk, some days you sprint! Chasing a dream requires you to do both (sic)”, tweeted KPCC president DK Shivakumar. The tweet from the Congress heavyweight comes after he was made to run, wielding the Congress flag, for about 100 metres by none other than his party leader Rahul Gandhi during the ongoing ‘Bharat Jodo Yatra’ at Basavanagudi Kenkere stretch near Huliyur in Tumakuru district.
  • It may be recalled that a few days ago, Rahul had made senior party leader Siddaramaiah run by holding his hand. Rahul’s initiative has been attracting mixed reactions from Twitterati. “This is cruel…please take care of your health Mr Shivakumar (sic)”, tweeted ‘Spare the Fundamentalist’.
  • “Many privileged politicians fancy cars at their disposal, would have never thought even in their wildest dreams that they would have to walk, sprint the stretch along with Rahul Gandhi”, tweeted another user Ravi. It appears Rahul wants to ensure that the rank and file of his party are in good shape and in the process he’s not sparing even the senior leaders.
  • Some say Rahul Gandhi wants to focus not only on the fitness of his party leaders and workers but also want to send a message that there’s no room for complacency in an election year. The former Congress president, while addressing a press conference recently, had said that the Bharat Jodo Yatra is different.
‘Want to understand people’s pain’
“By going in a car or in a plane or even reaching out to people through media is easy and comfortable for most political class who are now accustomed to it. I did not want to take the easy way out. I want to directly communicate with people and understand their pain and suffering,” Rahul had said. According to political pundits, gone are the days when Congress party candidates won elections hands down in the Nehru-Indira era. They have now realised that unless they reconnect with people on the ground, revival of the grand old party would be difficult.

Will bring JDS back to power in Karnataka: Deve Gowda

Highlights
  • Former Prime Minister and JDS supremo HD Deve Gowda said he will continue to make all efforts to strengthen the regional party and bring it back to power in Karnataka. “The JDS will again come to power in the state and Kumaraswamy will again become the CM. Let there be no doubt about it. I still have the energy to fight and will not allow any injustice to the state,” Gowda said, at the JDS ‘Janata Mitra’ convention in Bengaluru. He was addressing a public meeting after three months.
  • Gowda said once he recovers completely, he will visit all the districts. “We need to save the party. I have been asked to speak for only four minutes, but I will speak in detail (at the convention). I will also attend the party executive committee meeting.” For the past ten years, Kumaraswamy has been putting in a lot of effort to strengthen the party, Gowda said, adding that they have not done any injustice to any community, and took measures for the welfare of all communities.
  • Former chief minister H D Kumaraswamy slammed the Congress and BJP, blaming them for flooding, encroachment of lakes and stormwater drains in Bengaluru, and lack of proper health, housing and education systems. He accused the national parties of “looting taxpayers’ money” and doing nothing for the development of Bengaluru.
  • Gowda said that as part of the JDS’ Pancharatna programme plan, every ward and assembly segment in the state will have the best government institutions providing English and Kannada medium education up to Class 12, besides free health facilities to all.

Two killed in separate road accidents in Karnataka

Highlights
  • Two persons, including a woman, were killed in separate road accidents here on Sunday.
  • A 40-year-old woman was killed after a lorry hit her two-wheeler near the Nagarabavi underpass. The deceased Manjula was a resident of Vinayaka Layout in Nayandahalli and was a metre reader with Bescom.
  • The police said Manjula was riding towards Summanahalli in the morning when the lorry hit her bike from behind. The lorry ran over her killing her on the spot. The Byatarayanapura traffic police have registered a case and have arrested the lorry driver.
  • In another accident, a 26-year-old youth was killed after a mini-bus hit his two-wheeler on Ullal main road. The deceased Shreyas was a resident of Ullal and was working as a tele caller with a private firm. The police said that the mini-bus hit his bike from the front and Shreyas, who was not wearing a helmet, sustained fatal head injuries and died on the spot. The Kamakashipalya traffic police have arrested the bus driver.