KEY STORY
-
Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal on Sunday warned Pakistan saying it must stop petty politics. Addressing the AAP’s ‘Jan Aakrosh Rally’, Kejriwal said Kashmir will always be part of India.
-
He also lashed out at the BJP for its failure to protect the lives of Kashmiri Pandits and accused the Union government of stopping the people from taking out protests.
“When Kashmiri Pandits protest against the targeted killings, the present BJP government in Kashmir does not allow them to protest. If the government behaves like this, the suffering of the people becomes double,” he added.
The Delhi CM also said that many meetings were held by the current dispensation and everyone wants to know the action plan.
BJP can’t handle Kashmir as they only know how to do dirty politics, he said and urged the saffron party to not do politics over Kashmir.
Reacting to the recent targeted killings in Kashmir, the AAP national convenor said that the era of 1990 has come again.
“They don’t have any plans. Whenever there is a murder in the valley, news comes that the Home Minister has called a high-level meeting, enough of these meetings, and now we need action, Kashmir wants action. I will seek time to meet Amit Shah to discuss the current situation in J&K,” he added.
He also said that the Union government must cancel bonds signed with Kashmiri Pandits.
Days after several Kashmiri Pandit families left the transit camps in the Valley, the migrant employees said they won’t join their duty till the J&K Administration revoked the bond.
The signing of the bond makes their positing in the Kashmir Valley mandatory.
Under the PM’s Rehabilitation Package for migrant Kashmiri Pandits, the employees will be terminated from service if they seek transfer from the Valley for any reason.
KEY STORY
-
Noting that the contention of the insurance company that computing compensation under the head of ‘loss of future earning capacity’ only to disability arising from amputation defies logic and has no sanction of law, the Karnataka High Court said, adding that the Tribunals should bear in mind that compensation have to determined for disabilities due to injuries even without amputation in motor vehicle accident cases.
-
“In spite of vast progress in the field of science, humankind has not been able to establish a scientific method for making an exact estimation of the correlation between the physical disability suffered and impact it would have on his reduced capacity to earn in future. Inevitably, some amount of educated guess work needs to enter this domain,” the court said.
-
A division bench of Justice Krishna S Dixit and Justice P Krishna Bhat passed the order while allowing the appeal filed by a claimant seeking enhancement of the compensation. “The courts are enjoined under law to award ‘just compensation’ and no compensation can be regarded as just unless law is capable of reinventing itself by making proper adjustments as the ‘needs of the time’,” the court said.
CONCLUSION
-
“The materials produced before the Tribunal show that the claimant was running a tailoring business, which undeniably requires an able body and more particularly, a fully functional pair of lower limbs. It would be harsh, unrealistic, nay, almost nihilistic on the part of the Tribunal to ignore the philosophy of the Constitution of India in making their decision. Any disability, therefore, to any limb of the body which has a role to play in the functional-economic sense indubitably causes its effect on the body warranting curial intervention in its reparative and recompensing role,” the court said.
KEY STORY
-
Although a fourth wave of COVID-19 had been predicted in the last week of May or first week of June, the situation so far has been good in Karnataka. The latest genome sequencing data of SARS-CoV-2 in the State has not shown emergence of any new variants and the dominant variant of concern (VoC) continues to be Omicron BA.2 till May end.
-
According to genome sequencing data from the State Health Department, the presence of Omicron BA.2 that was detected in 87% of the sequenced samples in the first week of February has increased to 96.5% in May end.
-
Of the 1,647 samples sequenced in May, a total of 1,645 were Omicron infected. This included 1,587 (96.5%) samples infected with Omicron BA.2 and 58 that were infected with Omicron B.1.1.529. Only two samples had Delta and its sub-lineages.
During March and April, of the 2,364 COVID samples were sequenced. Of these, 2,162 (92.4%) were found to be infected with Omicron BA.2 variant. In February, 1,936 (89.8%) of the 2,155 samples sequenced had Omicron BA.2 variant.
No rise in hospitalisations
With a slight increase in the number of new cases in the last few days, there has been a marginal rise in the week-on-week caseload too. From 908 cases reported in the week prior to May 26, the number has increased to 1,338 in the week prior to June 2. However, no significant increase in clusters or hospital admissions has been noted during this period in the State.
-
Of the total 2,260 active cases in the State as of June 4, only nine patients have been admitted in hospitals. And all of them have occupied general beds in government hospitals.
-
State Health Commissioner Randeep D. told The Hindu that the rise in BA.2 variant had not translated into a huge spike of COVID cases in Karnataka, unlike in some countries. “Although this variant continues to be transmissible, the virulence has subsided both because of natural immunity and vaccine induced immunity,” he said.
Standard protocol
“Besides, the State now has a standardised treatment protocol for symptomatic COVID-19 patients. This has helped in both in-patient and out-patient care. A combination of these factors has ensured that although cases are slightly rising, the number of hospitalisations and deaths are minimal. However, the State has continued a vigilant approach in COVID surveillance,” the commissioner said.
Pointing out that a few family clusters were being reported only in Bengaluru, he said the vulnerable population including unvaccinated children and those with comorbidities continue to be at risk. It is essential for people to scrupulously follow COVID-19 mask usage and avoid crowding, the Commissioner added.
C.N. Manjunath, member of the State’s Clinical Experts Committee, said there is always a gap of four to six weeks between a surge in other States and Karnataka. “Although other States have been seeing a surge in cases for the past few weeks, the situation is holding on in Karnataka as of now. But we have to watch for another three-four weeks. Unvaccinated children and those who have not taken the booster dose should get vaccinated now,” Dr. Manjunath added.
KEY STORY
-
A day after Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai said the Karnataka textbook review committee has been dissolved and the State Government is open to relooking at concerns expressed by writers and seers, the Opposition Congress slammed the government and termed it as an attempt to mislead people.
-
Leader of Opposition in the Assembly Siddaramaiah said to put an end to confusion among students and teachers, the government must reject changes suggested by the committee and continue to use the earlier textbooks. Taking to social media, the former chief minister said Bommai should clarify if old or revised textbooks will be used for teaching in the current academic year.
-
Many writers have withdrawn the permission given to use their writings in the textbooks and have also warned the government of taking legal action, the Badami MLA said and questioned the government on how can such content be part of textbooks. Siddaramaiah also sought legal action against Rohit Chakrathirtha for insulting Kannada and writers.
-
Leader of Opposition in the Council BK Hariprasad said the State Government has dissolved the committee but wants to retain the revisions made by it. The Congress leader said students, writers and seers have expressed displeasure and the government should take action against Rohit Chakrathirtha.
DKS visits NSUI activists in jail
TUMAKURU: Karnataka Pradesh Congress Committee (KPCC) president DK Shivakumar on Saturday met the National Students Union of India (NSUI) workers, who were arrested following a demonstration in front of the houses of Primary and Secondary Education Minister BC Nagesh recently, at the district prison here.
“Just for burning the RSS ‘chaddi’ the police have filed cases against them. Did they burn the National Flag?” he thundered. Shivakumar said it was clear from the video clippings of the incident that the NSUI workers did not commit any mistake as they staged the protest outside the minister’s house.
KEY STORY
-
Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai, who recently visited Davos, inked deals with many companies and bagged investment commitments worth Rs 65,000 crore. But entrepreneurs and CEOs have been expressing their displeasure over the basic infrastructure problems of the capital city — Bengaluru. Will this dampen the spirit of investors?
-
In an interview with The New Sunday Express, Aravind Melligeri, Chairman and CEO of Aequs, a diversified contract manufacturing company, said business activities should be spread beyond Bengaluru.
What is the confidence level in the industry on investments coming into the state in the face of incidents of polarisation occurring across Karnataka?
Karnataka has always maintained a positive outlook on inviting and encouraging investors. The present situation remains optimistic as the government continues to support growth through progressive policies. The state’s stance is forward-looking and its policies have led to the development of technology, R&D capabilities and an easy access to workforce, which has attracted investors. The long-term outlook remains positive. With the state promoting investments in industries such as defence and technology, Karnataka will continue to be looked at positively by investors.
The state government announced investment proposals of Rs 65,000 crore with at least Rs 52,000 crore committed. How do you think this will spur economic activity across the state?
The investments committed will spur and amplify economic activity while ensuring that the state maintains its position as a great place to do business. If the investments fructify, they will surely increase industrial activity. As companies set up new facilities across the state, it will give rise to the implementation of newer, advanced technologies, while R&D centres will future-proof technological growth. However, it is important that the government ensures that these investments become a reality.
The CM says competition for investments is at a global level and not among the states. What does Karnataka need to do to stay competitive at the global level?
Karnataka has significant human capital, both skilled and unskilled, and investor-friendly environment. It can easily compete with countries like Vietnam, which is of a similar size as that of Karnataka in terms of available human capital.
There is a push for investments beyond Bengaluru. What needs to be done to spruce up infrastructure across the state beyond the state capital?
The potential is definitely beyond Bengaluru. Apart from the fact that Bengaluru was reaching saturation, it is also true that there are resources in the hinterland that the industry needs to utilise. The time is now ripe to capitalise on this and showcase the capabilities that the rest of the state rightly possesses. The mission to go beyond Bengaluru and develop industrial clusters across Tier II and III cities will require huge investments, more specifically to develop infrastructure.
What is needed to be done in Bengaluru on the infrastructure front?
Bengaluru has reached saturation and continues to be plagued by infrastructure woes. No matter how much investment you pump in, it may not keep pace with the influx of people and development. Decongesting is the only solution. This means business activity now has to spread beyond the boundaries of the city.
What do you think about reservation in the private sector? Do you think it should be introduced?
Skill development centres to train any available unskilled labour that is willing to work, coupled with the creation of job opportunities in the hinterland, should take away any need for reservations.
Highlights
-
In yet another case of ‘violence’ against Kannada-speaking people in Andhrapradesh, a group of miscreants allegedly assaulted a KSRTC bus driver and conductor in Srisailam.
-
It is said that the bus was traveling from Vijayapura to Srisailam. The incident took place on June 2 when the driver and conductor were sleeping inside the bus at the Srisailam bus stand.
-
Around midnight, a group of people barged inside the bus and began attacking the duo. However, they were rescued by the locals after they heard the duo scream for help.
-
The bus driver Basavaraj Biradar has been severely injured in the incident. Following this, a case was registered at the nearby police station.
-
Earlier, two people from Karnataka were injured in the violence which started as a verbal duel between a pilgrim and a local shop owner in Srisailam.
Highlights
-
KALABURAGI WITH INPUTS FROM HYDERABAD: A pleasure trip to Goa turned tragic for two families from Hyderabad as two couples and their children were among the seven who were charred to death in a bus that went up in flames after meeting with a road accident near Kamalapur in Kalaburagi district of Karnataka on Friday.The victims were identified as Arjun Gudur (37), his wife Saraladevi (35), their daughter Vihan (4), Shivakumar (35), his wife Ravali (30) their son Vikshit ( 9) and Anita (40), wife of Rajeshwar Rao, all residents of Risala Bazar and Kamatipura in Hyderabad.
-
Police sources said that another 16 people sustained injuries, three of whom are serious and are being administered treatment in private hospitals in Kalaburagi.In all, a 37-member group, including two drivers and a conductor, had left for Goa from Hyderabad on May 28 and started their return journey from Panaji at about 8.30 pm on Thursday when the mishap occurred near Kamalapur.
Driver was reckless, say pax
Passengers said that they had warned the driver twice aga-inst rash driving, but he continued to drive recklessly.
Highlights
-
Former chief minister Siddaramaiah, the man credited with uniting the Ahinda (Kannada acronym for minorities, backward classes and Dalits) vote and bringing the BJP government to its knees over the iron ore mining scam, will have a dedicated ‘Siddaramotsava’ convention when he turns 75 on August 12.
-
His followers are planning a three-day mega convention in Davanagere to celebrate the milestone. The celebration comes at a time when a cold war is brewing between Siddaramaiah and KPCC president DK Shivakumar over the chief ministerial candidate. The event is seen as political muscle-flexing ahead of the 2023 Assembly polls.
-
Before joining Congress, Siddaramaiah held Ahinda conventions in 2005-06. The movement played an important role in his political career and he later became chief minister with full majority in 2013. A senior leader, requesting anonymity, said around 10 lakh people are expected to take part in the celebration. “Siddaramaiah was one of the few chief ministers to complete the full five-year term. He launched many pro-people schemes, including Anna Bhagya and Indira Canteen. Several experts will talk about such achievements of Siddaramaiah at the event,” the leader said.
-
A book on his achievements is also expected to be released. Many senior central leaders are likely to take part. The organisers are also planning to invite senior BJP leader BS Yediyurappa. Incidentally, Siddaramaiah was the only leader from Congress to take part in the birthday celebrations of Yediyurappa two years ago when the latter was the chief minister.
-
While sources said it is an attempt to project Siddaramaiah as the chief ministerial candidate, it may not go down well with Shivakumar. HC Mahadevappa, a close associate of Siddaramaiah, said that the issue has not been discussed formally in party forums. “We still have time for the celebrations as his birthday falls in August,” he said. Not revealing any further information, he said the party leaders are now busy with the Council and Rajya Sabha polls. Siddaramaiah, who lost the Assembly elections in 2018 at his home constituency Chamundeshwari in Mysuru, had won from Badami in Bagalkot.
SIDDU WARNS OF ‘CHADDI BURNING’ STIR ACROSS STATE
BENGALURU: Continuing his tirade against the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), Leader of Opposition Siddaramaiah warned that Congress will launch a “chaddi burning” demonstration across the state if action is not taken against BJP workers, who allegedly assaulted NSUI members outside Education Minister BC Nagesh’s house in Tiptur, Tumakuru, recently. Siddaramaiah said the police action against NSUI workers was unwarranted as the protestors did not attempt to set fire to the house.
Highlights
-
Congress, which put up a united front during the two-day ‘Nava Sankalpa Shibira’, will compile the suggestions from the brainstorming sessions and formulate a Karnataka Declaration, a blueprint of the party’s agenda for the 2023 Assembly polls. The declaration, which will be announced in two days, will include the party’s commitment to protection of minorities and job reservation for SC/STs and OBCs, even in the private sector, if the party comes to power.
-
Withdrawing the Kasturirangan report on the Western Ghats to safeguard the interests of farmers will also be part of the Congress declaration. After the valedictory of the Shibira, KPCC president DK Shivakumar stressed that since Muslims and Christians are being “oppressed” under the BJP government, the Congress will stand by them. “We will get to work under a collective leadership and come back to power using the BJP government’s failures as our weapon,” he said.
-
The party will rake up issues related to price rise, the state not repealing the “anti-farmer laws” despite the Centre withdrawing them and alleged corruption in the Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai-led BJP government. From August 9 to 15, the party will launch ‘Padayatras’ in all districts and conduct ‘Nava Sankalpa Sshibira’ in all district headquarters, Shivakumar said.
-
Providing 33 per cent reservation to women and appointing office-bearers from block level by giving representation based on the castes is also the party’s priority. Leader of Opposition Siddaramaiah said the party will urge the Centre to continue the GST compensation, which is likely to be stopped after five years from June 30, 2022.
-
About 600 delegates in six groups held discussions for about 12-13 hours on various topics, including economics, health, education, women empowerment, social justice and others. Former deputy chief minister Dr G Parameshwara, former Union minister Rahman Khan and KPCC campaign committee chairman MB Patil were present.
Highlights
-
Telangana Chief Minister K Chandrashekar Rao (KCR) expressed deep shock and grief over the ghastly road accident that occurred in Karnataka on Friday where seven persons belonging to Hyderabad died.
-
He also announced an ex-gratia of Rs 3 lakhs to the next of kin of Telanganites who died and Rs 50,000 to those who were injured in the mishap. The Chief Minister also directed to make all arrangements to bring the bodies to Hyderabad.
-
Accordingly, Chief Secretary Somesh Kumar directed the Sangareddy district collector to coordinate with the counterpart of Karnataka and arrange to shift the bodies and injured.
-
The incident took place around 6.30 a.m. in the outskirts of Kamalapur taluk in Kalaburagi district on the Bidar-Srirangapatna highway. The bus was travelling from Goa to Hyderabad.
-
Police sources said that the bus had caught fire after colliding with a lorry. The bus then collided with the bridge and also veered off the road due to the impact of the accident. More than 35 passengers were traveling on the bus at the time of the accident.
-
The private bus belonged to the Orange company in Goa. The locals were not able to go near the bus as it caught fire soon after the collision. They informed the police, Fire Brigade, and Emergency services.
Highlights
-
Age is just a number. This has been proved right by two brothers of Kodagu who are making their district and state proud by actively participating in various sports championships held for senior citizens across the country. Palekanda P Bopaiah (94) and Palekanda Beliappa (85), residents of Kuttandi village in Kodagu district, have now set their eyes on participating in track and field championships to be held in in Sydney and Japan next year.
-
The Palekanda brothers recently took part in the Pan India Master Games held in Bengaluru and won three gold medals and two silver medals. By taking part in javelin throw, relay race, 1,500 metre running race, walkathon, 100 metre run, the two brothers call themselves all-rounders.
-
“Both of us stay together in our village. I have been passionate about sports from the time I was a kid and my schoolmates could never match my speed in athletic events when I was a young boy. My elder brother is a retired Army man. Both of us decided to resume our participation in sports field over three years ago and we haven’t looked back since,” said Beliappa.
-
The brothers have also set up a Master Games Association for senior citizens in Kodagu and are working out the modalities to enable senior citizens to become its members.“My first participation in sports championship as a senior citizen was at Vadodara. I won the third place in the National Masters Game. Ever since, I ensure that I take part in all championships that are held for senior citizens across the country. Both my brother and I are now looking forward to taking part in the athletic championships scheduled to be held in Sydney and Japan next year ,” he added. However, the duo needs at least Rs 2 to 3 lakh fund to take part in the international championship and are eagerly looking forward to sponsorship.
Highlights
-
AICC General Secretary in-charge of Karnataka Randeep Singh Surjewala has said that the Congress has decided to set up a state-level war room to coordinate in the run up to the party’s campaign for the 2023 Assembly polls in the state. “Karnataka is a state where people have started talking in favour of the Congress.
-
The state-level war room will be set up in 20 days”, he said at the two-day brainstorming session ‘Nava Sankalpa Shibira’ of the Karnataka Congress at a resort in Devanahalli near here on Thursday.Admitting that some of the Congress leaders in Karnataka were unhappy over the party’s recent choices to the MLC and Rajya Sabha polls, Surjewala said such disappointments should not turn into dissensions. “The resolutions adopted at the Shibira will pave the way for the Congress to return power,” he said.
-
He claimed that only the Congress can restore the glory of the state. He came down heavily on the Bommai government alleging that it has put a lid on employment and encouraged jobs for sale racket besides destroying progress, peace and prosperity which is in the DNA of the state’s people.On Friday, the Congress will announce the ‘Bengaluru declaration’ by putting together the discussions deliberated at the Shibira.
-
Leader of Opposition in the Assembly Siddaramaiah felt that the Congress should come to power not just for its own sake but to safeguard people from the BJP. He elaborated on the issues related to price rise and saffronisation of the education sector.
-
Meanwhile, Siddaramaiah and KPCC president DK Shivakumar showcased a rare bonhomie as they left the venue in the same car to an undisclosed location after lunch giving rise to speculation about Rajya Sabha polls as the fourth seat has become a headache for all the three major political parties as none have the adequate numbers.
Highlights
-
Hundreds of government school teachers gathered at Freedom Park on Thursday, protesting against the government’s refusal to transfer them to their home districts, according to a recent amendment to the Transfer of Teachers Act. In September last year, an amendment was made to the Karnataka State Civil Services (Regulation of Transfer of Teachers) Act, 2020, allowing teachers a one-time option for a transfer back to their home districts.
-
The teachers said that many of them have been working in their non-home districts for the past 10 years, and for years their transfers are pending. They have launched the protest after the government refused to transfer them due to lack of vacancies. “We’re asking for transfers so that we can get postings in or closer to our home districts and we are able to see our families,” one of the protesting teachers said on condition of anonymity.
-
“We’re happy to be transferred even within the same zilla so that we can visit our children and families. Especially for those of us with small children who are away from our families, we cannot find people who are willing to look after them,” another teacher said. Many of the teachers had suffered due to the long-distance, either due to divorces, being unable to visit their children.
Highlights
-
KALABURAGI: At least 4 persons were charred to death and many people sustained injuries when a Hyderabad-bound Goa bus collided head-on with a goods vehicle and later dashed to the roadside bridge near Kamalapur town, about 35 km from Kalaburagi, on Friday morning.
-
Police sources told Express that the diesel tanker was damaged after the bus dashed to the bridge and suddenly the bus was caught in the fire.
-
In all, there were 35 people on the bus and all were from Telangana. Police sources said that a single has booked seats for 20 persons and another person booked 6 seats. As per the preliminary information, 11 people who sustained injuries were admitted to different hospitals in Kalaburagi.
-
As of now no bodies were lifted as there is a lot of heat in the accident spot. The death toll may increase. The police are yet to identify the bodies.
-
The driver of the goods vehicle sustained injuries. The driver of the bus is safe and police have taken him into custody.
Highlights
-
The India Meteorological Department (IMD) has forecast heavy rains in Karnataka for four days following which a Yellow alert has been issued in Bengaluru and coastal regions.
-
The Bengaluru city, Bengaluru Rural, coastal districts of Dakshina Kannada, Uttara Kannada and Udupi are to witness heavy showers.
-
The rain is going to lash Hassan, Shivamogga, Ramanagar, Kodagu and Chikkamagalur districts.
-
Heavy rainfall is also predicted in Mysuru, Mandya, Chamarajanagar districts of south Karnataka. Yellow alert has been sounded in Bengaluru and coastal districts.
-
It has also been warned of rain with lightning and thunder in most districts of the state. Bengaluru will experience lightning and thunderstorms on Friday and Saturday.
-
North Karnataka districts of Bagalkot, Bidar, Gadag, Koppal, and Raichur will not be affected by rainfall.
-
A yellow alert is a signal of just watch and the weather condition during this alert is heavy rain from 7.5 to 15
(With inputs from IANS
KEY STORY
-
The Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) on Thursday released a guidance document for use of drones in healthcare for medical supplies in far-flung areas. The research body has come up with this document after using the drones for delivering Covid-19 vaccines in the northeastern states of Manipur and Nagaland.
-
As per the guidance document, the Covid-19 vaccines and serums with storage temperature between 2AoC and 8AoC, tablets and capsules, syrups in bottles, gloves, syringes, blood bags, diagnostic biological tissues, urine, blood, sputum, saliva or frozen specimens can only be transported by drone.
-
“As a nation with 1.3 billion, we have faced several challenges in upgrading our healthcare system. The Covid pandemic further added to this challenge but also gave us an opportunity to revisit some of the issues and fix them. With the advent of Covid-19 vaccines, ICMR envisaged the delivery of these vaccines to hard-to-reach-terrains in India. This guidance document will assist in understanding different nuances involved in planning and execution of drone-based delivery of medical supplies,” Prof Dr Balram Bhargava, Director General of ICMR, has said in the foreword of the document.
-
The scientists from ICMR collaborated with Ministry of Civil Aviation (MoCA), Government of India, Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA), Airport Authority of India (AAI) to produce this document in compliance with the New Drone Rules-2021 which highlights the ways of selecting drones, choosing takeoffs and landing sites etc.
The scope of this document covers areas such as how to obtain regulatory approvals from competent authorities for various kinds of drones and utilising air space for delivering medical supplies restricted to medicines, vaccines and surgical materials. It also underlines the ways of selecting suitable drone models and criteria for choosing take-off and landing points for drones.
KEY STORY
-
Several educators and academicians in Karnataka have urged the state government to revoke the revision of school textbooks, claiming that it is “extremely disturbing and antithetical to the core values of our education system and constitution.” Educationists and activists wrote to the Karnataka government, requesting that the government to print and supply the school textbooks that have been in use for many years following the previous modification.
-
The state government was criticised by student and teacher organisations in May for allegedly omitting a lesson on Bhagat Singh from the Class 10 textbook. B C Nagesh, the state’s school education minister, denied that the lesson had been removed.
-
In a letter, the educators said-
Textbook revision – an unnecessary, divisive, and costly exercise
We strongly urge the Government of Karnataka to:
1. Revoke the recent revisions to the textbooks, which are regressive in nature, and have been done in an arbitrary manner, without adherence to well-defined curriculum framework and processes.
2. Print and supply the textbooks which have been in use for many years, post the last revision
3. Focus energies on addressing the serious education emergency in the state, prepare a roadmap, allocate sufficient resources and implement programs to enable the children of marginalized and poor communities to overcome learning deprivation due to the pandemic
Background
The government of Karnataka has recently undertaken revision of Kannada and Social Science textbooks, in which some chapters have been removed and few added. The process and substance of the textbook revision is deeply disturbing and antithetical to the core values of our education system and constitution, for several reasons:
Undemocratic
The Government of Karnataka constituted a committee of seven men who took the decisions to add and drop chapters, without the broad consultation that has characterized textbook preparation in the past. In sharp contrast, the 2014 Baraguru Ramachandrappa committee, worked through 27 committees comprising 172 experts to revise the textbooks, and held several public consultations to hear diverse views. It is not known if the Chakratheertha committee held any public consultations in its process. The preparation of textbooks is a process that requires a high sense of responsibility, as textbooks are the primary resource to which lakhs of young minds will be exposed. Academic experts, teachers, and eminent citizens are usually consulted to get diverse inputs which enables the textbook revision exercise to stay free of biases of a few people, which process has not been followed.
Secondly, at the time the committee was setup, the Education Minister had announced that the committee would first submit a report which would be studied, and only then the revision would be done. However, there is no evidence that the committee submitted a report for public discussions, preceding the revision.
Non-representative
The composition of the textbook revision committee does not reflect the reality of Karnataka society. Almost all the members of the committee are Brahmin men. The chapters dropped consist of writings of Dalit writers and progressive writers, while the chapters added are written by Brahmins. It seems that the committee has pushed the ideology of the dominant religion/caste in this process. Lack of diversity and representativeness undermines the committee’s credibility. Denial of perspectives of those who have suffered social injustice over centuries, reinforces those injustices.
Regressive
Diversity and exposure to cultures other than our own is essential for broadening a student’s thinking, for developing respect for others, and for building a harmonious society. The revision violates these aims of education articulated in the eponymous position paper of the National Curriculum Framework 2005. One of the dropped chapters discusses the injustices of the caste system. Another dropped chapter discusses vegetarian and meat cuisine. A third chapter where content has been dropped is of the noted social reformer Periyaar, who provided a different perspective on the Ramayana. Casteist content has been added – for instance, a reference to the upanayana ritual of Brahmin men, in the chapter on Basaveshwara, whose primary vision was of a casteless society. The Baragur Ramachandrappa committee was setup to remove the errors and biases inserted into the textbooks by the previous committee, including a claim in the science textbook that the Dronacharya was born through in-vitro fertilization (test tube baby). Now more than ever, is the need to build a scientific temper and respect for plurality to find rational and empathetic solutions to the challenges posed by the pandemic. True education would lie in providing diverse perspectives and discussing these in an open manner, to provide opportunities to develop critical thinking in children. One-sided propaganda loses the respect of the teacher and the taught, undermining the very values the content may seek to build.
Costs children of the state heavily
The majority of children of Karnataka have suffered a catastrophic situation during the pandemic, without access to structured learning opportunities and textbooks. They need a variety of learning materials, including textbooks, which should reflect the ideals of social justice, democracy, egalitarianism and India’s common cultural heritage (NCF 2005). Unfortunately, this revision has cost the children of the state dearly — due to this exercise, textbook printing has got delayed for at least 3 months (which is an entire semester).
When politicians play curriculum games, it is the children who suffer. — National Coalition on the Education Emergency.
The NCEE is a group of individuals, organizations and networks across the country which have come together to ‘resume and renew’ school education. [email protected] | www.educationemergency.net
Educators comments
“Instead of enhancing the content of the text books to reinforce constitutional principles of equality, social justice and democracy, it is a shame that the Karnataka government has actually removed some of the chapters that espoused such values. What is special and unique to India’s democracy is its respect for all religions, languages, regions, cultures and so on. The harm done to the fabric of society through such manipulation of text books would sow seeds of disharmony, mistrust and divisiveness. It would hit at the core of imagination of India as a secular democratic nation”. – Smt. Shanta Sinha, ex-chairperson of the National Commission on the Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR)
When the state and civil society should be working together to support teachers post the massive disruption to education caused by the pandemic, it is unfortunate that Karnataka is embroiled in unnecessary controversies over the past year. – Prof. Mythili Ramachand, member of the Karnataka D.El.Ed curriculum revision committee. One would assume that textbooks and the education of our children need to rise above political leanings and biases, especially in a large diverse, complex country like India. One of the foundational principles stated to guide NEP 2020 is “respect for diversity and respect for the local context in all curriculum, pedagogy, and policy, besides adhering to Constitutional values. The Karnataka textbook revision exercise is antithetical to all this. Dr. Maya Menon, Teacher Educator.
Any decision related to choice/inclusion of content in the curriculum or textbooks should be dictated by curricular priorities of which development in children of critical thought and analysis and appreciation of diversity is acknowledged to be the need of the hour in the 21st century. Decisions on the basis of ideological leanings should therefore not be acceptable by the school system – Prof Venita Kaul, Professor and Director of School of Education Studies, Ambedkar University (retd.)
For almost a thousand years since Basava, Karnataka has formed its identity in terms of a lively dialectic between the ‘living presence of a teacher’s mind’ and the ‘dominant national narrative’. What defines Karnataka is the rich history of the tension between the two. The Chakratirtha Committee appears to have set aside the historical reality of ‘the being of Karnataka’ as well as the principle of inclusion that Dr. Ambedkar embedded in the Constitution. – Prof. GN Devy.
The entire process is undemocratic, opaque and not following the principles of natural justice – Dr Niranjanaradhya, Development Educationist, Mentor of SDMCs and Chief Advocate of Neighbourhood Common School System through State Funded Public Education.
A group of brahmin men adding references to regressive caste practices (upanayana in the chapter on Basaveshwara), removing content analyzing the injustices inherent in caste system, in an opaque exercise, violates the constitutional ideals of equality and social justice – Gurumurthy K., National Coalition on the Education Emergency.
HIGHLIGHTS
-
Authorities in Karnataka are on high alert as some activists of Hindu organisations said that they will ‘enter’ Jamia masjid in Srirangapatna in Mandya district, on June 4 and perform puja there.
-
The Hindu organisations have also decided to approach the court to demand a survey of the masjid along the lines of the Gyanvapi mosque. They have given calls on social media and in various events to participate in the ‘Srirangapatna Chalo’ programme.
-
Sources said that the authorities are waiting for instructions from the government as to how to handle the devotees who may try to enter the masjid and perform ‘puja’ there.
-
The district authorities have already beefed up the security in and around the Jamia masjid. They are also contemplating clamping prohibitory orders from June 3 and extending it to June 4.
-
Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) and Bajrang Dal leaders, who are at the forefront of the ‘Srirangapatna Chalo’ movement, have said that since the district authorities have not responded to their request, they are going ahead with their plan.
-
The mosque authorities have already expressed apprehension and made appeals to the government to protect it.
-
Built by Tipu Sultan in 1786-87, Jamia mosque is also called as Masjid-i-Ala and is located inside the Srirangapatna fort. The mosque has three inscriptions that mention nine names of Prophet Mohammad.
-
The Narendra Modi Vichar Manch organisation, which had made submissions to the authorities for a survey of the mosque, said that they strongly believe that the Jamia masjid was built after razing down a Hanuman temple. They quote B. Lewis Rice, a British historian, archaeologist and educationist, in his report to the Archaeological Survey of India in 1935, had mentioned a Hanuman temple on Page number 61.
HIGHLIGHTS
-
The textbook controversy, which pertains to state syllabus schools, is also impacting junior school levels under the Indian Certificate of Secondary Education (ICSE) and Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) boards.
-
As the textbook committee is facing allegations from all sides over omissions and inclusions of chapters in class 10 textbooks, the Karnataka Textbook Society is taking cautious steps in releasing and printing of textbooks for lower grades.
-
They are also being cautious in the release and printing of Kannada textbooks to be supplied to Central Board for Secondary Education (CBSE) and Council for Indian School Certificates Examination (CICSE) schools, which are following state syllabus for second and third languages. The supply of textbooks to children of lower grades even from class 3 and 4 have been affected due to this.
-
The offline academic year for most schools has started and students have resumed classes after a gap of two years. While most textbooks, following the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) syllabus, have been distributed to students, the distribution of textbooks where Secondary School Leaving Certificate (SSLC) syllabus is to be followed, is being delayed.
-
“All books have been given to children, except the Kannada textbooks. Parents have been of the delayed supply as they are yet to be printed. Every year the supply of textbooks is delayed, but a date is set for the supply. This year there has been no communication from the textbook society of when it will be supplied. We are taking photocopies of some chapters from that of last year’s books and they will be given to the children in a week’s time,” said a principal of a leading CBSE school.
-
In some other cases, the school management has asked wards to arrange for textbooks from students who have passed to higher grades so that they can be given to their juniors, till new stock comes. A senior education department official told The New Indian Express: “Reviewing the rising request from schools, when we inquired, Society members said that the textbook committee and the Society members were exercising caution and going through all the chapters to ensure there is nothing controversial. In some places the education officers are also going through the textbooks contents.”
Reacting to this, M P Madegowda, Society, Managing Director said, tenders and work orders for 527 titles have been given and 69% of printing has been fully completed. Based on the approval of the Deputy Director of Public Instructions the printing is being done.
Byju’s may soon train students for exams
Mangaluru: Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai on Wednesday said the state government is holding talks with the country’s largest ed-tech company — Byju’s — to provide training in all competitive exams. He said the government has already held one round of talks with Byju’s.
Highlights
-
With just hours to go for the withdrawal of nominations for the Rajya Sabha polls, Congress and JDS were busy trying to convince each other to support their candidate in the crucial elections. Congress and JDS do not have the numbers to win the fourth Rajya Sabha seat on their own strength and have to depend on the other party’s support. Congress has 70 seats and does not have the numbers to send a second candidate, while JDS with just 32 MLAs cannot even send one candidate to the Upper House. Congress sought support from JDS, arguing that it is a national and secular party, while JDS tried to convince Congress saying it is a regional secular party with only one seat in the RS and needs one more seat. The negotiations are also difficult as the two parties don’t trust each other.
-
If Congress’ Mansur Ali Khan withdraws and his party supports JDS candidate Kupendra Reddy, JDS will win or vice-versa. If both don’t come to an agreement and decide to slug it out, BJP’s third candidate and MLC Lehar Singh Siroya will breast the victory tape as the saffron party has more votes than its two opponents.
- On Tuesday, JDS MLC TA Sharavana called on Congress Legislature Party leader Siddaramaiah requesting him to get Mansur Ali Khan to withdraw. But the former chief minister requested Sharavana to get JDS candidate Kupendra Reddy to pull out, saying Congress needs the numbers in the Upper House and that JDS being a secular party should support Mansur Ali Khan from the minority community.
-
Congress supporting JDS is not new as it came to the aid of HD Deve Gowda when his party faced a similar situation two years ago and got him elected to the Rajya Sabha.
-
But their relationship soured after JDS allied with BJP to get its MLC Basavraj Horatti elected as chairman of the Legislative Council. A confident BJP MLC and general secretary Ravi Kumar told TNIE, “If no one withdraws, then the BJP candidate will automatically win because of sheer numbers.”Asked if BJP will withdraw, he said, “Certainly not. We will explore all legitimate options to win because we have sufficient votes to get all the three elected.’’
1...181182183...442Page 182 of 442