Hijab an innocent practice of faith: Petitioners tell Karnataka HC

KEY STORY

  • The Muslim girls who have moved the Karnataka High Court against the ban on Hijab argued on Tuesday that wearing the headscarf was an innocent practice of faith and not a mere display of religious jingoism.
  • They also requested the full bench of the HC to make a leeway to attend classes with headscarves as the court’s interim order had suspended their ‘fundamental rights’.
  • Dwelling on Article 25 of the Indian constitution before the bench, senior counsel Devadatt Kamat, appearing for the Muslim girls from Udupi pre-university college, said the article speaks about ‘freedom of conscience’.
  • “This (freedom of conscience) has a lot of depth in that term. The essence of Article 25 is it protects the practice of innocent faith and not a mere display of religious identity or jingoism,” Kamat told the full bench of the High Court comprising Chief Justice Ritu Raj Awasthi, Justice J M Khazi, and Justice Krishna M Dixit, constituted to hear the Hijab row following commotion and violence on campuses as it turned out into a Hijab versus saffron row.
  • Article 25 deals with “Freedom of conscience and free profession, practice, and propagation of religion.”
  • The Muslim girls have challenged the Karnataka government’s February 5 order which restricted students from wearing clothes that could disturb peace, harmony, and law and order.
  • According to the counsel, wearing Rudraksha or putting a Nama (Tilak or vermillion on the forehead) was similar innocent faith as people who put it feel protected by the divine and a connection with the creator.
    “To counter that (Hijab), if somebody wears a shawl (saffron shawl), they will have to show whether it is a display of religious identity alone or is it something more. If it is sanctioned by Hinduism by our Vedas, Upanishads, our scriptures, our lordships are duty bound to protect it. If not, then the Article 25 does not protect,” Kamat argued.
  • The senior lawyer also cited Sonali Pillai case where she had challenged in the court the school’s order restricting her from wearing a nose ring stating that if they allowed it the school will become ‘a parade of the horribles’.
  • The girl won the case in the court of law, Kamat said.
  • Stating that the an innocuous practice of wearing head scarf and not changing the uniform was a facet of freedom of speech and expression, he sought an exemption to wear headscarf as it was in line with right to freedom of speech and expression.
  • Kamat also questioned the argument of the government banning clothes that could lead to commotion saying that it was an impermissible argument.
  • He pleaded before the bench not to continue its interim order restricting the students from wearing Hijab or saffron scarves as it ‘suspends the fundamental rights’ of the Muslim girls.

CONCLUSION

  • Arguing on behalf of Muslim girls, advocate Ravi Varma Kumar said his clients were restricted entry on December 28 citing code of conduct of the institution. According to him, the government has not yet taken a decision on the uniform dress code
  • Kumar further said the government order on February 5 did not speak about Hijab per se.
  • Referring to the Karnataka Education Act, he said the College Development Committee is a non-existent body under the said Act.
  • “It is an extra-legal authority, which is now endowed with the power to prescribe the uniform,” the lawyer argued.
  • The court adjourned to Wednesday further hearing of the case.

India vs West Indies: Virat Kohli on verge of breaking Martin Guptill’s elite T20I record at Eden Gardens

KEY STORY

  • Indian batting icon Virat Kohli is on the verge of overtaking New Zealand opener Martin Guptill and becoming T20I cricket’s highest run-getter. Kohli needs to score 73 runs to overtake Guptill and move up to the top spot on the list of most runs in the history of T20I cricket.
  • Currently, Guptill is leading the list with 3299 runs to his name. Kohli is a close second with 3227 runs while Indian white-ball captain Rohit Sharma is third with 3197 runs. The Indian duo is followed by Australian skipper Aaron Finch and Ireland’s Paul Stirling who have 2676 and 2660 runs to their name.
    Highest run-scorers in T20I cricket history 
    1) Martin Guptill- 3299
    2) Virat Kohli – 3227
    3) Rohit Sharma – 3197
    4) Aaron Finch- 2676
    5) Paul Stirling- 2660
  • Kohli was top of the list until a few months back when Guptill overtook him during New Zealand’s tour of India last year. Kohli had taken a rest from the series following the conclusion of the 2021 Men’s T20 World Cup.
  • While both Rohit and Kohli have the opportunity to upstage Guptill, the current and former Indian captain could also complete 1000 runs as a pair in T20I cricket. They are 58 runs away from achieving the milestone.
  • Virat Kohli is coming into the series on the back of his worst ODI series in almost nine years. Kohli made just 26 runs in three matches in a three-match battle against West Indies at Ahmedabad’s Narendra Modi Stadium.

HD Deve Gowda dials Telangana CM K Chandrasekhar Rao, extends support in effort to unite opposition against BJP

KEY STORY

  • Former prime minister and Janata Dal (Secular) president HD Deve Gowda, on Tuesday, spoke to Telangana Chief Minister K Chandrasekhar Rao and extended support to his fight against alleged ‘polarisation politics’ by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). A release by the Telangana Chief Minister’s Office (CMO) said that Deve Gowda promised to meet KCR in Bengaluru to deliberate upon the issue.
  • “Rao Saab, you are fighting very well. Everyone should fight against the communal elements. To protect our country’s secularism, culture, and diverse culture we will be with you and support you. Continue your fight and our total support will be there for you,” Gowda was quoted as saying in the CMO release.

    Will meet Thackeray, WB CM: KCR

    On Sunday, KCR had said that he would soon be holding meetings with Maharashtra Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray and West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee in an effort to unite the opposition against the BJP. He also said that he may travel to Mumbai soon to hold a meeting with Thackeray.
    Rao, who has been critical of the BJP government at the Centre has even previously said that he would be playing a major role in uniting non-BJP political parties against the ruling party.
  • “The whole country is silent on the hijab issue, What will happen if this type of hatred in Karnataka is spread across the nation? Hate politics should be avoided. All the political forces in the country should unite and oust the BJP,” Chandrasekhar Rao had recently said.
  • Besides Rao, Tamil Nadu Chief Minister MK Stalin had, on Sunday said that CMs of non-BJP-ruled states would soon convene a meeting in Delhi.

TAC recommends daily tests in Karnataka to be limited to 75,000 under revised strategy

KEY STORY

  • In view of a steady decline in the incidence of COVID-19 cases and Test Positivity Rate (TPR), both in districts and the capital, the COVID-19 Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) has recommended that Karnataka can reduce its testing target to 75,000 from the current daily tests of around 1.2 lakh. After deliberations on this issue at its 155th meeting on Sunday, the TAC said while 25,000 tests should be conducted in Bengaluru daily, the remaining 50,000 should be done in the rest of the State.
  • “Indian Council of Medical Research’s (ICMR) guidelines on purposive testing strategy of COVID-19 issued on January 10, 2022 should be duly followed and only symptomatic persons should be tested,” stated the TAC’s report.
  • In mid-January, when the pandemic was raging like wildfire across the country, the TAC advised the State to go slow on testing. It had recommended that random testing should be stopped and the focus should only be on symptomatic persons. For some time (when the transmission was very high after January 18), Karnataka was doing over 2 lakh tests and the daily target was reduced following the TAC’s recommendation.
    Genome sequencing

     

  • Besides, the TAC has said that all samples from hospitalised patients, particularly from high dependency units (HDU) and ICUs apart from cluster outbreaks, should be sent for genomic sequencing without fail.
  • TAC member V. Ravi, who is also the nodal officer for genomic confirmation of SARS-CoV-2 in Karnataka, said it is important to genome sequence samples of all hospitalised patients to understand the cause and variant behind the disease severity in them. “This is also mandated by Indian SARS-CoV-2 Genomics Consortium (INSACOG),” he said.
    “At this juncture when the third wave is waning, it would be vital to take up facility-based surveillance as there is no point in testing asymptomatic contacts of positive individuals in the community,” he explained.
    No test before surgeries
  • Taking a cue from AIIMS, New Delhi, and PGIMER, Chandigarh, where screening of asymptomatic patients for COVID-19 before admission, surgeries, procedures, and investigations were stopped from February 10, the State’s TAC has recommended that a similar system should be put in place in both government and private hospitals in Karnataka too.
    “The hospital infection control committee (HICC) should play a dynamic and proactive role in this regard. However, testing, isolation, and treatment of symptomatic patients should be continued as per existing guidelines,” the report stated.
  • TAC sources said non-COVID-19 patients have been badly hit owing to the non-availability of efficient services in the hospitals ever since the pandemic hit the State in March 2020.
    Arundathi Chandrashekar, State Mission Director, National Health Mission (NHM), said a circular on the revised testing targets and no requirement of COVID-19 test before surgeries will be issued in a day or two.

Hijab row: BJP, Kateel delete tweets revealing personal details of petitioners

KEY STORY

  • The official Twitter handles of Karnataka BJP unit and its president Nalin Kumar Kateel drew flak for tweeting the personal details of Muslim students who have moved the High Court in the hijab case.
  • In the now deleted tweets, names and addresses of the six students were revealed by the handles, inviting sharp criticism for violating the privacy of minors.
  • The BJP tweet read, “(sic) Five of the students involved in #HijabRow are minors. Don’t CONgress leaders Sonia, Rahul & Priyanka have any guilt for using minor girls to stay relevant in politics? How low will they stoop to win elections? Is this what “ladki hoo lad sakti hoon” means.”
  • Kateel, in a Kannada tweet, noted that four of the petitioners with respect to the Hijab row were minors. “What does it mean when these minors link hijab row to elections in five states. Doesn’t it mean that these students are dolls dancing on someone else’s tunes?” he wrote.

CONCLUSION

  • Among those criticising the tweet was Shiv Sena MP Priyanka Chaturvedi, who urged the National Commission of Protection of Child Rights to take up the issue. “This is a criminal act to share names and addresses of minors. This is unacceptable,” she said.
  • Several other Twitter users also contended that sharing address of minors, as mentioned in a court petition, amounted to doxxing. However, few others maintained that the details were available in the petition filed in the High Court for everybody to access.

No restrictions on hijab in degree colleges: Minister

KEY STORY

  • With colleges set to reopen on Wednesday, Minister for Higher Education C.N. Ashwath Narayan has clarified that no uniform is stipulated in degree colleges, and hence, students are free to wear the dress of their choice.
  • The Minister told mediapersons at Chamarajnagar, ‘’But in schools and pre-university colleges where a dress code or a uniform has been prescribed, it is imperative to follow the rules.”
  • Mr. Narayan said the matter is being heard by the High Court of Karnataka, and there is an interim order, which everyone should abide by.
    ‘’The rules were not framed overnight. They are not in favour of, or against anyone, but for the collective good, and they should be adhered to,” he said.

    Arguments with teachers

     

  • Meanwhile, cases of high school students being barred entry for wearing hijab, citing High Court interim order, continued on February 15.
  • Students wearing hijab and their parents entered into arguments with school staff in parts of Shivamogga, Chikkamagaluru and Hassan districts. Several students spoke to the media questioning the government’s rule on the issue and that teachers had not read the High Court’s interim order fully. They argued that the interim order, which banned hijab and saffron shawl, was for colleges, and not schools.
  • Further, they said girls were covering their heads with a veil, which is a part of the school uniform. “Our children are not violating the uniform. What is wrong if they cover their heads with the veil, which is a part of the uniform?” said one parent.
  • Many students reached the Government High School at Indavara in Chikkamagaluru taluk wearing hijab. They were accompanied by their parents. When the school staff told them not to enter the premises with the hijab, they argued that they had the right to wear hijab. The parents, who stood by their children, said they want their children to get quality education and hence they would insist their children are not sent back home. The SSLC students were not allowed to take the preparatory examinations.
  • As school authorities found it difficult to handle the situation, they declared a holiday after taking permission from senior officers. Parents opposed the decision and said that schools should not be closed as the final examinations are approaching.

     

  • Meanwhile, a boy took out a saffron shawl from his bag. The police deployed at the school intervened and succeeded in convincing him to put it back in his bag.
  • A similar incident was reported in Mudigere where a girl argued that she had the right to wear hijab and nobody, including her parents, could force her to remove it.
  • In Shivamogga, a few girls walked out of Karnataka Public School as they were not allowed inside wearing hijab. On February 14 too, 13 students had skipped SSLC preparatory examinations.
  • A student told mediapersons that her parents had told her to return home if she was not allowed to enter the school with hijab. She argued that nobody had the right to ask her to remove her head scarf.
  • Similar incidents were reported at Shiralakoppa and Shikaripur in Shivamogga district, and at Belur in Hassan district.
  • At a meeting convened by the College Development Committee of Government PU College at Ripponpet in Hosanagar taluk in Shivamogga district, some students made it clear that they would not attend classes on February 16 if they were not allowed to wear hijab.

Karnataka High Court quashes law banning online gaming

KEY STORY

  • The Karnataka High Court on Monday struck down the amendments to the Karnataka Police Amendment Act in 2021 prohibiting certain online gaming activities. A division bench comprising Chief Justice Ritu Raj Awasthi and Justice Krishna S Dixit said that nothing in the judgment shall be construed to prevent an appropriate legislation in accordance with the constitution.
  • The bench declared certain provisions of the Karnataka Act number 28/2021, to the extent the provisions pertaining to regulate online gaming activities, to be ultra vires to the Constitution of India. “The consequences of striking down the provisions shall follow. However, nothing in this judgment shall be construed to prevent an appropriate legislation be brought about concerning the subject of betting and gambling, in accordance with the provisions of the constitution. A writ of mandamus is issued restraining the respondents from interfering with online gaming business and allied activities of the petitioners,” the bench said.
  • The state government by amending the Karnataka Police Act, 1963, had prohibited and criminalised playing of games of skill including online games by risking money or otherwise. The petitioners, including All India Gaming Federation, claimed that games such as poker, chess, rummy, fantasy sports are all games of skill and various court orders have categorically differentiated games of chance and games of skill.

Govt to ban 54 Chinese apps posing threat to national security: Sources

KEY STORY

  • The Central government has issued fresh instructions to ban 54 Chinese apps calling them a threat to privacy and national security, said sources on Monday.
  • Reportedly, a large number of these mobile applications belong to tech giants like Tencent, Alibaba and NetEase. Some of these apps include Beauty Camera: Sweet Selfie HD, Beauty Camera – Selfie Camera, Equalizer & Bass Booster, CamCard for SalesForce Ent, Isoland 2: Ashes of Time Lite, Viva Video Editor, Tencent Xriver, Onmyoji Chess, Onmyoji Arena, AppLock, Dual Space Lite.
  • It should be noted that these applications are largely rebranded and rechristened avatars of apps that have already been banned in the country since 2020.
  • In its latest order, the ministry of electronics and IT said that these apps were transferring sensitive data of Indians to servers in foreign countries such as China.
  • It also directed top app stores including Google’s Playstore to block these applications. A govt official confirmed, “The 54 apps have already been blocked from being accessed in India through the PlayStore.”
  • Since June 2020, the government has banned a total of around 224 Chinese apps starting with about 59 apps in the first round, including popular applications like TikTok, PUBG, Shareit, WeChat, Helo, Likee, UC News, Bigo Live, UC Browser, ES File Explorer, and Mi Community.
  • While PUBG Mobile, somehow made a comeback in India with Krafton setting up a new office and cutting ties with its Chinese partners, TikTok hasn’t been that lucky and continues to be banned in the country.

Siddaramaiah demands Karnataka govt to release caste census report

KEY STORY

  • Leader of Opposition Siddaramaiah urged the state government to accept the Social, Economic and Educational census report to lift the blockade faced in holding elections to local bodies of the state.
  • Karnataka Leader of the Opposition Siddaramaiah. Credit: DH File Photo
    Leader of Opposition Siddaramaiah urged the state government to accept the Social, Economic and Educational census report to lift the blockade faced in holding elections to local bodies of the state.
  • “The recent judgement by the Supreme Court on reservation to Other Backward Castes in local body elections has created a blockade to the reservation to OBCs. It is possible to resolve the issue with Social, Educational and Economic Survey conducted by the State Backward Classes Commission,” he said.
  • On January 20, the Supreme Court had reiterated a three-pronged criterion to mandate OBC reservation for local bodies, failing which elections cannot be held. The criterion included a Commission to study the OBCs and implications of the OBC quota in local bodies and specify the proportion of reservation for the OBCs.
CONCLUSION
  • “The state BJP government should immediately accept the survey carried out by the Backward Classes Commission,” he said, adding that it should present the same report to the Supreme Court and argue the case to prevent injustice to the OBCs.
  • Instead of using the Supreme Court order as the reason to postpone Zilla and Taluk Panchayat elections, the government should immediately use these reports to convince the court to hold elections at the earliest, he said.

JDS supremo HD Devegowda blames national parties for Hijab row

KEY STORY

  •  Expressing unhappiness over the Hijab crisis JDS supremo HD Devegowda said on Sunday that the hijab issue could have been resolved by the leaders of national parties through dialogue instead of making futile attempts to take political mileage.
  • Addressing the media here after attending JDS workers’ meeting  he said that unfortunately the matter became the national issue due to inelegance by the leaders of the state government and opposition leaders. Gowda said that the leaders of the national parties took up the issue as a prestigious one by raising unwanted matters in this regard.
  • He also opined the political leaders could have shown unity when the sensitive issues rose.  The Hijab issue is before the High court and it would be better to maintain peace till pronouncing the verdict.
  • It is also the responsibility of every citizen to respect the court orders in the interest of the nation.  Earlier while addressing the workers Gowda said that he would never keep quiet till bringing the JDS to power alone and nobody can restrict HD Kumaraswamy from becoming the chief minister after 2023 assembly elections in the state.
  • Section of opposition leaders started targeting the JDS by airing false statements against JDS to take the political advantage in 2023 assembly elections saying that JDS would finish politically as Gowda and HDK never come out  as they were suffering from different ailments and  HD Revanna cannot lead the party in future.
  • JDS will emerge one of the strongest regional parties in future, he added. He prayed to lord Kukke Subramanya to give health to further strengthen the party, he added. Warning the leaders against giving trouble for the senior leaders and sincere workers in the party Gowda said that let them quit instead of humiliating the leaders.
  • Hinting surprise candidates for for 2023 elections, Gowda said that  he decided to tour all the districts and select the candidates for 2023 assembly elections after studying the pros and cons. He also take the local leaders and workers in to confidence before finalizing the candidature.
  • Gowda expressed unhappy for alleged differences in the party in Arkalgud assembly constituency.  AT Ramaswamy, KM Shivalingegowda, CN Balakrishna MLAs didn’t attend the workers meeting. HD Revanna, KM Lingesh MLAs  and HK Kumaraswamy JDS state president were present.